25 Best Pudding Recipes That Don't Come from a Boxed Mix
So good, you'll lick it straight from the pan.
Every item on this page was chosen by an editor from The Pioneer Woman. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.
Though many of us have come to know and love packaged pudding, you'll be excited to learn that making your own homemade pudding is easier than you might think. The simple, no-bake dessert is made on a stovetop in just a few minutes, and the results are creamy, comforting, and perfect for serving as a snack or after an easy family dinner.
Here, you’ll find pudding recipes in all different flavors including vanilla, butterscotch, and lemon-coconut. You can keep things simple by serving them in bowls with a bit of whipped cream or get creative with your pudding by turning them into beautiful trifle recipes or parfaits. Whether you’re craving a chocolate dessert or something more fruity, ahead you’ll find a pudding recipe that’s right for you.
The best part about pudding is that you can enjoy it all year round! While the pumpkin pudding will taste great on a chilly fall night, the key lime pie pudding is perfect for a summer afternoon. And if you're anything like Ree Drummond's husband Ladd, you'll take a slice of chocolate pudding pie any time of year. Along with your classic creamy puddings, we've also included rice pudding, bread pudding, and a chia pudding that doubles as a healthy dessert. So the next time your craving a sweet treat, keep these delicious pudding recipes in mind—your family will love them, too.
Chocolate Pudding Pie
This is Ladd Drummond's favorite dessert and we can see why! It's simple, delicious, and there's nothing fussy about it. All you need is your favorite pie crust and a creamy chocolate pudding.
Get Ree's Chocolate Pudding Pie recipe.
Lemon Coconut Pudding
These little pudding cups are packed with lemon and coconut flavors, and they're like a little vacation in the form of dessert .
Get the Lemon Coconut Pudding recipe.
Chocolate Pudding
If we're talking pudding, we have to include a classic chocolate recipe. Adding a mini graham cracker crust to the bottom is the key.
Get the Chocolate Pudding recipe.
Layered Chocolate Pudding Dessert with Salted Pecan Crust
Layers of chocolate pudding, cream cheese, and Cool Whip make for an indulgent summer dessert, great for serving at a backyard party.
Butterscotch Pudding
This butterscotch pudding will be practically begging for you to eat it, enjoyed with a generous dollop of whipped cream.
Get Ree's Butterscotch Pudding recipe.
Rice Pudding
The bourbon-soaked raisins on this dessert will turn everyone into a rice pudding lover.
Get Ree's Rice Pudding recipe.
Coconut Chia Pudding
You may know that chia seeds are packed with nutrients, but you may not realize that they also make for a delightfully smooth coconut pudding, too.
Get the Coconut Chia Pudding recipe.
White Chocolate Croissant Bread Pudding
Okay, so technically, bread pudding is a custard not a pudding. But with the end result being so creamy and dreamy, we couldn't resist adding this one to the list. It's made out of croissants!
Vanilla Pudding
This creamy, homemade vanilla pudding can be paired with your choice of berries and cream, or enjoyed all on its own.
Get the Vanilla Pudding recipe at Butter with a Side of Bread.
Dark Chocolate Pudding
This dairy-free pudding is extra creamy, thanks to the two avocados in the recipe. That means lots of extra protein hidden inside, too!
Get the Dark Chocolate Pudding recipe at Two Peas and Their Pod.
Tapioca Pudding
Tapioca pearls give this five-ingredient dessert its classic texture. For best results, look for the small pearls as they cook easier.
Get the Tapioca Pudding recipe at Tastes Better From Scratch.
Homemade Banana Pudding
Serve up this Southern staple with a dollop of homemade meringue. Lightly toasting it gives it extra flair!
Peanut Butter Pudding
This from-scratch recipe is described as "scrape-the-pan good," which is all you really need to know if you love peanut butter. Topping with crushed peanuts adds a delicious contrast in texture.
Get the Peanut Butter Pudding recipe at The View from Great Island.
Sicilian Strawberry Pudding
Sound fancy and call it gelo di fragole! Or simply call it delicious. With just seven ingredients and 15 minutes of hands-on time, you'll be impressed just how amazing each bite is.
Get the Sicilian Strawberry Pudding recipe at The Mediterranean Dish.
S'mores Pudding
Rich chocolate pudding gets a serious upgrade in this s'mores dessert, layered with graham crackers and toasted marshmallows. No campfire required!
Coffee Pudding
Calling all coffee lovers! This java-infused pudding is made with both strong black coffee and instant coffee granules. Plus, it’s a good excuse to eat pudding for breakfast.
Eggnog Pudding Parfaits with Ginger Snaps
You'll definitely want to be home for the holidays when these little cups of goodness are ready! Layers of eggnog-flavored pudding are alternated with spicy gingersnaps for a delectable treat. You can also omit the alcohol if you need.
Get the Eggnog Pudding Parfaits with Ginger Snaps at Brown Sugar Food Blog.
Key Lime Pudding
Lovers of key lime pie will adore this thick pudding. It tastes similar to the filling of the favorite dessert but without the hassle of making a crust.
Pumpkin Pudding
It takes just four ingredients to put this delicious pumpkin treat together. Go ahead and whip up a batch in the any time of year―we won't tell!
Cheesecake Pudding
The base for this pudding is made with cream cheese and sour cream so it’s extra creamy and tangy. Top it with graham cracker crumbs and a swirl of fruit jam for the perfect dessert.
Get the Cheesecake Pudding recipe at Just a Little Bit of Bacon.
Caramel Desserts Full of Sticky-Sweet Goodness
Make Homemade Cream Cheese Frosting in 10 Minutes
Easy Fall Desserts You Can Bake in an Hour or Less
How To Make Ree's Dr Pepper Sheet Cake
