Skip to Content

40 Italian Christmas Dinner Ideas for a Big Family Feast

Calling all pasta lovers!

By
italian christmas dinner ideas
Danielle Daly

Every item on this page was chosen by an editor from The Pioneer Woman. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.

A traditional Italian Christmas dinner is something that anyone can appreciate—no matter what your background might be! That’s especially true if you’re a pasta lover like Ree Drummond is (she considers it one of her favorite food groups)—or if you’re simply a fan of those traditional Italian Christmas desserts like homemade tiramisu. Either way, you'll find it all here on this list of Italian Christmas dinner ideas.

First things first, pick from festive Christmas appetizers like crab-stuffed mushrooms or an antipasto plate in the shape of a wreath then open up a bottle of Italian wine and get ready to dig in. Then you’ll find cozy Italian dinner recipes, like chicken saltimbocca, hearty lasagna, braised beef, and stuffed artichokes. Plus, there are plenty of ideas for a big Feast of the Seven Fishes: Shrimp scampi and grilled lobster tails are just two tasty ideas!

Of course, it wouldn't be an Italian-style feast without a mouth-watering selection of Christmas treats! Here, you'll find Christmas cookies, like pizzelle and cannoli, along with a traditional struffoli that’s made with bite-sized fried dough tossed in honey. There's also an affogato, which is like serving your after-dinner coffee and dessert all in one. It’ll have everyone at the table saying, "Buon Natale!" (That's "Merry Christmas" in Italian. 😉)

1

Garlic Knots

garlic knots italian christmas dinner
Caitlin Bensel

It really doesn't matter what you're making for the main course, because some sort of garlicky bread will go with it. Try making knots this year! They're so pretty, and more importantly, they're slathered in a lot of garlicky butter.

Get the Garlic Knots recipe.

SHOP BAKING SHEETS

2

Antipasto Skewers

antipasto skewers italian christmas dinner
C.W. Newell

Make your charcuterie board easier to guests to handle―literally! Place their favorites like salami, cheese, and pickle veggies on skewers so they can grab and mingle.

Get the Antipasto Skewers recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3

Chicken Parm Lasagna

chicken parm lasagna italian christmas dinner
Ryan Liebe

Why choose between lasagna and chicken parmesan when you can make both in one dish? To save prep time, you can use both jarred marinara sauce and pre-cooked rotisserie chicken.

Get Ree's Chicken Parm Lasagna recipe.

4

Rainbow Cookies

rainbow cookies italian christmas dinner
Caitlin Bensel

These colorful almond cookies will win any cookie swap for sure! Sandwiched in between the moist layers, you'll find raspberry jam and then there's a coating of chocolate on top.

Get the Rainbow Cookies recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5

Italian Meatball Soup

italian meatball soup italian christmas dinner
Will Dickey

If you want a starter course to warm everyone right up, then serve them a soup that's just hearty enough. Little meatballs and a sneaky amount of veggies will get everyone in the mood for even more.

Get Ree's Italian Meatball Soup recipe.

SHOP SOUP BOWLS

6

Baked Spinach Ravioli with Pesto Cream Sauce

baked spinach ravioli pesto italian christmas dinner ideas
Danielle Daly

While this dish has layers bursting with flavor, it actually comes together in less than an hour. That's because you can use a jar of pesto and store-bought ravioli to save a lot of time.

Get Ree's Baked Spinach Ravioli with Pesto Cream Sauce recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

Ricotta Cheesecake

ricotta cheesecake italian christmas dinner
Will Dickey

Christmas cheesecake, but make it Italian! Ricotta results in a lighter and fluffier version than an American-style cheesecake. Top with pistachios and chocolate shavings for a contrast in texture.

Get the Ricotta Cheesecake recipe.

8

Creamy One-Pot Sausage Gnocchi

creamy one pot sausage gnocchi italian christmas dinner
Stacy Allen

Give those store-bought gnocchi a glow up! Adding spicy sausage and making a creamy sauce is just the start, too. The best part may be at the end: topping it with garlicky, buttery breadcrumbs.

Get the Creamy One-Pot Sausage Gnocchi recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9

Affogato

affogato italian christmas dinner
Will Dickey

If you want to serve coffee and dessert all in one, look no further! Affogato is a simply a scoop or two of gelato with freshly brewed hot espresso poured over top, so you can put it together in just a few minutes.

Get the Affogato recipe.

10

Eggplant Rollatini

eggplant rollatini italian christmas dinner
Antonis Achilleos

This baked casserole is one of Ree's favorites! It's also an easy recipe to make and store in your freezer ahead. When you're ready to serve, just pop it in the oven for a cheesy, saucy holiday dish.

Get Ree's Eggplant Rollatini recipe.

SHOP CASSEROLE DISHES

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11

Spaghetti With Clams

spaghetti with clams italian christmas dinner
LUCY SHAEFFER

Sometimes, simple is best! Case in point: This easy yet impressive classic dish. You'll find a lot of the ingredients in your fridge or pantry. And you can even swap out for canned clams if you can't find fresh.

Get the Spaghetti With Clams recipe.

12

Chicken Piccata

chicken piccata italian christmas dinner
Will Dickey

This chicken recipe is a great way to brighten up your holiday meal. The creamy sauce is a luscious combination of white wine, butter, and lemon juice.

Get Ree's Chicken Piccata recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13

Stuffed Artichokes

stuffed artichokes italian christmas dinner
Danielle Daly

These artichokes are filled with golden breadcrumbs, garlic, anchovies, and parmesan. It's a flavor-packed bite that's best served with melted butter for dipping.

Get the Stuffed Artichokes recipe.

14

Struffoli

struffoli italian christmas dinner
Will Dickey

This traditional dessert is visually stunning with its festive Christmas sprinkles and charming wreath shape. But it's more than just that. It's also deliciously tasty thanks to the mini fried dough balls tossed in honey.

Get the Struffoli recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
15

Manicotti

manicotti italian christmas dinner
Danielle Daly

These tube-shape noodles are filled with a four-cheese mixture then covered with a hearty homemade meat sauce. For extra cheesiness, they're covered in a layer of melted mozzarella.

Get the Manicotti recipe.

SHOP COOKWARE

16

Slow Cooker Bolognese

slow cooker bolognese italian christmas dinner
Will Dickey

A classic meaty red sauce is easy to make when you let your slow cooker do the work. Pair it with fettuccine or any pasta shape you choose.

Get the Slow Cooker Bolognese recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
17

Cannoli

cannoli italian christmas dinner
Will Dickey

This Sicilian pastry looks just like the kind that lines the shelves of your favorite Italian bakery! They have crisp shells, a smooth ricotta filling, and fun decorations, like mini chocolate chips and chopped pistachios.

Get the Cannoli recipe.

18

Pumpkin Risotto

pumpkin risotto italian christmas dinner
Caitlin Bensel

This seasonal twist on risotto incorporates real pumpkin puree to make the dish creamier than ever. The hint of sweetness is perfect for pairing with salty bacon, crispy sage, and pumpkin seeds.

Get the Pumpkin Risotto recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
19

Crab-Stuffed Mushrooms

crab stuffed mushrooms italian christmas dinner
Caitlin Bensel

Maybe it's the flavorful crab meat, the crunchy panko breadcrumbs, or the melty cheese, but whatever it is, this elegant seafood starter is always a hit.

Get the Crab-Stuffed Mushrooms recipe.

20

Chicken Cacciatore

chicken cacciatore italian christmas dinner
Hector Manuel Sanchez

This family-friendly dish all comes together in a big dutch oven, including the crispy chicken thighs, veggies, and white wine sauce. Serve it over noodles for the ultimate Italian feast.

Get the Chicken Cacciatore recipe.

SHOP DINNERWARE

Watch Next 
italian christmas dinner ideas
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below