Skip to Content

40 Unique Christmas Cookies That Will Stand Out on the Dessert Table

One might just become your new favorite!

By
unique christmas cookies pinwheels
Caitlin Bensel

Every item on this page was chosen by an editor from The Pioneer Woman. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.

There's no tradition as sweet as baking Christmas cookies. From classic cookies like gingerbread and sugar cookies to Ree Drummond's favorite Christmas cookies that she's been making since childhood—there are so many types of cookies worth trying. And while the traditional treats never get old, there's always room on the cookie plate for something different. We're talking about the most unique Christmas cookies that your friends and family might not expect.

So, before your next holiday cookie swap, add these treats to your Christmas baking list. Here, you'll find fun shapes like gingerbread cowboy boots and sugar cookies shaped like Santas, along with unique flavors like coffee-infused cookies and cookies that taste just like cinnamon rolls! And if that wasn't enough, we've also included options for cookies inspired by Texas sheet cake, chocolate truffles made out of cookies, and the most adorable cookies that look like mini apple pies.

Many of these options are even part of the ultimate Christmas cookie collection, so you know they're worth trying! With this list of Christmas desserts, you'll never get tired of the same-old cookies. Whether it's a twist on an old-school favorite like thumbprint cookies filled with dulce de leche or something entirely new, you'll want to make them year after year. Looking for more baking inspiration? Try our Christmas cupcakes or peppermint recipes for even more holiday flavor.

1

Chocolate Sugar Cookies

unique christmas cookies
David Malosh

Just like real snowflakes, these pretty cookies each have their own special design. You'll use a powdered sugar icing and sanding sugar to decorate them.

Get Ree's Chocolate Sugar Cookies recipe.

SHOP COOKIE CUTTERS

2

Holiday Haystacks

unique christmas cookies
Will Dickey

Making unique cookies doesn't have to be hard! These no-bake treats are easy to whip up using crunchy bits like chow mein noodles and nuts that are tossed into melted chocolate. Don't forget to adorn them with sprinkles!

Get Ree's Holiday Haystacks recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3

Red Velvet Thumbprint Cookies

unique christmas cookies
David Malosh

The red coloration of these cookies makes them so festive! After you make an indentation in the center of each ball with your thumb, you'll pipe or spoon a dollop of cream cheese filling in the middle.

Get Ree's Red Velvet Thumbprint Cookies recipe.

4

Cut-Out Sugar Cookies

unique christmas cookies
C.W. Newell

Cowboy boot cookies will be a fun surprise when placed next to treats in typical Christmas shapes. You can make them even more fun by adorning them with a simple but vibrant royal icing.

Get Ree's Cut-Out Sugar Cookies recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5

Sugar Cookie Biscotti

unique christmas cookies
C.W. Newell

Colorful sprinkles make these biscotti so merry and bright! They're also made unique thanks to a delightful sugar cookie flavor. Make the milk glaze for dipping and drizzling, then serve them alongside a pot of coffee.

Get the Sugar Cookie Biscotti recipe.

SHOP RAINBOW SPRINKLES

6

Fruitcake Cookies

unique christmas cookies
C.W. Newell

You've heard of fruitcake—but fruitcake cookies? Now, that's special! They're perfectly spiced and studded with candied fruit and nuts. A sweet brandy glaze is even added on top.

Get Ree's Fruitcake Cookies recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

Lemon Meltaways

unique christmas cookies
C.W. Newell

These little lemon cookies are called meltaways because, well, they melt in your mouth! Along with the light and luscious base, you'll have a simple glaze made of lemon juice, lemon zest, and powdered sugar.

Get Ree's Lemon Meltaways recipe.

8

Peppermint Sugar Cookie Bars

unique christmas cookies
David Malosh

Want to put a special spin on classic sugar cookies? Make them in bar form! Better yet, add a festive frosting made with peppermint extract and sprinkled candies.

Get Ree's Peppermint Sugar Cookie Bars recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9

Cranberry Orange Oatmeal Cookies

unique christmas cookies
David Malosh

Dried cranberries and grated orange zest give these cookies a seasonal flavor that everyone will enjoy. To finish them off, drizzle with sweet white chocolate!

Get Ree's Cranberry Orange Oatmeal Cookies recipe.

10

Ree's Favorite Christmas Cookies

unique christmas cookies
Will Dickey

Since you can use cookie cutters to shape these simple sugar cookies however you'd like, they'll definitely be unique! Just be sure to have a variety of icing colors and sprinkles on hand to decorate.

Get Ree's Favorite Christmas Cookies recipe.

SHOP PIPING BAGS

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11

Gingerbread Cookie Sandwiches

what are cloves
Will Dickey

We all know and love gingerbread cookies, but what about gingerbread cookies filled with orange buttercream and jellied cranberry sauce? They're the definition of sugar, spice, and everything nice!

Get the Gingerbread Cookie Sandwiches recipe.

12

Cinnamon Roll Cookies

cinnamon roll cookies
Will Dickey

Ree once said she loves delivering a batch of cinnamon rolls to friends and family come Christmas, and now, there's cinnamon roll cookies to give out, too! They have all the sweet, buttery goodness of a warm cinnamon roll in an easy slice-and-bake cookie form.

Get the Cinnamon Roll Cookies recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13

Chocolate Toffee Cookie Bars

chocolate toffee cookie bars
Will Dickey

Calling all toffee lovers! Get your fix with this recipe that takes chewy brown sugar cookie bars and combines them with homemade toffee. We're talking all the butter and caramel you could dream of!

Get the Chocolate Toffee Cookie Bars recipe.

14

Eggnog Cut-Out Cookies

eggnog cut out cookies
Will Dickey

The festive red and green swirled icing on these sugar cookies is just part of what makes them so wonderful! They're made with real eggnog, egg yolks, and nutmeg for a taste that's just as delicious as they look.

Get the Eggnog Cut-Out Cookies recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
15

Baklava Bites

baklava bites
Will Dickey

Set out a batch of these baklava bites at your next holiday party and watch how fast they're eaten up! Frozen phyllo pastry cups are filled with a sweetened, buttery pistachio and walnut mixture that's baked until golden then drizzled with honey syrup.

Get the Baklava Bites recipe.

SHOP PHYLLO PASTRY CUPS

16

Espresso Biscotti

espresso biscotti
Will Dickey

You'll want to have a cup of coffee on hand so you can dunk this delicious dessert! Espresso powder gives the biscotti a deep golden-brown color and rich coffee flavor. We're also loving the chocolate drizzle!

Get the Espresso Biscotti recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
17

Mint Fortune Cookies

mint fortune cookies
Will Dickey

Green gel food coloring gives these yummy mint fortune cookies and oh-so-Christmassy finish! And yes, you can fill them with cute Christmas messages or jokes to delight all of your family and friends.

Get the Mint Fortune Cookies recipe.

18

Italian Peach Cookies

italian peach cookies
Will Dickey

If you really want to impress your guests this holiday season, try your hand at an Italian Christmas dessert. They're almost too cute to eat and just as delicious—made by taking hollowed out vanilla cookies and filling them with fluffy buttercream flavored with peach preserves.

Get the Italian Peach Cookies recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
19

Red Cherry Thumbprint Cookies

red cherry thumbprint cookies
Johnny Miller

Everyone at your Christmas dinner will give a big thumbs up to these thumbprint cookies! The delicious dough is easy enough to make and bake, then decorated with festive red sanding sugar and finished with a red candied cherry in the center.

Get Ree’s Red Cherry Thumbprint Cookies recipe.

20

Pizzelle

pizzelle cookies on sheet pan
Caitlin Bensel

This thin, crisp cookie is traditional in Italy, but it might be unique to you—especially when made with confetti color sprinkles or cocoa powder for a twist.

Get the Pizzelle recipe.

SHOP BAKING TOOLS

Watch Next 
unique christmas cookies pinwheels
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below