50 Best Secret Santa Gifts Under $25 That Everyone Will Enjoy
They'll be so glad you joined the exchange party.
Every item on this page was chosen by an editor from The Pioneer Woman. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.
If you haven't put a ton of thought into your Secret Santa gifts in the past, you're not alone! This fun Christmas tradition is intended to be lighthearted and informal, so a small, inexpensive stocking stuffer will do just fine. Right? Well... sort of. You don't have to budge on the "inexpensive" part, by any means, because there are so many great gifts for every budget: gifts under $20, gifts under $30, and even gifts under $10. Why not try to brighten your recipient's holiday season with an item that's a little more creative than usual—or simply one that speaks to their personal interests?
This list of the best Secret Santa gift ideas will help you do exactly that. Each and every item is reasonably priced at under $25, but boasts tons of holiday appeal. We've got you covered with unique ideas that they probably don't own already. Need to surprise a food lover? Try a mini waffle maker or a fun snack tray for their Stanley tumbler. Or make your favorite beauty guru smile with some self care masks that pamper them from head to toe.
Some of these options are quite universal and useful, so they'll make excellent white elephant gift ideas that will be the envy of the entire exchange. Regardless of what you choose, your Secret Santa this year is bound to be a lot more interesting. They'll definitely be glad you were their Santa, that's for sure!
Imagine if all you had to do to make a cocktail was to add a little kit to your favorite spirit. Well, The Cocktail Box Co. makes that dream a reality! This fun kit comes in nine different flavors.
We can see why this fun find is racking up lots of five-star reviews. Not only are they cute and comfy scrunchies, but they have secret pockets to hold essentials like keys and cash.
You're bound to know multiple people at this point that lug around a giant Stanley tumbler. This little bowl sits atop a 40-ounce bottle for any kind of snack they'll want while they sip away.
Hours of fun will be had with this karaoke microphone! All you need to do is pair it with a streaming music, and you're ready to sing the night away.
If you actually, you know, like your Secret Santa, why not splurge a little? This silk eye mask still clocks in at less than $25, but it's an undoubtedly luxurious find.
Western enthusiasts will appreciate these darling cookie cutters, which come in a set of two and feature a cowboy hat and boot. They're an excellent choice for any at-home baker.
Who would have thought that ground coffee would be a great exfoliator? These richly scented handmade soaps are perfect for the coffee and chocolate lover in your life.
Funny, decorative, and all-around wonderful, this throw pillow will thrill any sweet tooth.
Your recipient can place one of these magnetic timers on their fridge, oven, or microwave to ensure their cooking and baking adventures go smoothly. You can choose a color that truly suits them, too—several options are offered.
At under $20, these floral coasters make for a great, inexpensive Secret Santa gift. A cork bottom keeps them from scratching your recipient's table.
Notes of cypress, evergreen, cedar, and fir make up this delightful candle's fragrance. It's perfect for wintertime.
Playing with your food is allowed with this mug around! It's a must-have for any kid at heart.
How cute are these stars? This sweet bracelet will remind them of Christmas all year long.
Cheese fanatics will flip for this very relevant, very delicious book. It's adorable enough to be placed right on their coffee table.
Avocado toast lovers will appreciate this nifty tool. It splits, pits, and slices any ripe avocado with ease.
What's the holiday season without a big, warm scarf? This classic plaid option will keep them cozy all the way until spring.
"If you can read this, bring me some wine," reads the text on these funny socks. They're the ultimate gift for your aspiring mixologist friend—or just the one who loves wine.
If they always have a tough time deciding between an after-dinner cup of coffee or a glass of wine, this is the gift for them. Merlot-infused beans and hints of currants and blackberries give it an out-of-this-world taste.
You'll be their favorite Secret Santa ever if you nab them one of these personalized notebooks. (And you don't have to admit to them that it was actually under $10!)
Whether or not you're a '90s kid, odds are you appreciate a good throwback when you see one. This old-school Tamagotchi comes in seven different colors.
AnnMarie Mattila is the Senior Editor for The Pioneer Woman, covering a wide range of topics from food and cooking to home, beauty, style, and more.
You Can Make These Easy Appetizers Ahead of Time
Corn Muffins with Honey Butter Are a BBQ Must
Bonne Maman's Advent Calendar Is Back for 2025
How To Make Pull-Apart Garlic-Herb Biscuits
